I have to agree about the FMA dubs- they were awful. Part of speech that were so touching and yank at your heart became really pointless difficult to listen to.
Hmm...I guess I'm alone in thinking it was okay =/ I mean I did like Ed is japanese better than Vic's voice but I think Vic captured whiny angry Ed quite well. Also Al sounded great and Lust was, well, Lusty lol. I will agree that the original was better though. Usually is but I remain to be a dub fan anyways

Ni-paa~